Released Wild
Centros y voluntariado

Biden Administration Reinstates Federal Bear Baiting Ban

The Biden administration has reinstated a ban on bear baiting using foods like bacon on federal lands in Alaska, reversing a Trump-era rule.

The Biden administration has reinstated a ban on bear baiting using foods like bacon on federal lands in Alaska...

The Biden administration has reinstated a ban on bear baiting on federal lands in Alaska for 2024. This action reverses a Trump-era rule that permitted hunters to use foods like bacon and doughnuts to attract bears. The rule was published by the US Department of the Interior in the Federal Register and is set to take effect in mid-November. The administration cited scientific evidence showing the practice makes bears more aggressive and puts park visitors' lives at risk.

The Obama administration first instituted the federal ban. The first Trump administration later overturned it. Court proceedings ultimately upheld the Obama-era rule, overturning the Trump administration's decision. The Biden administration's 2024 move reimplements that original prohibition.

Regulatory Context

The rule change published by the Interior Department follows a complex legal and administrative history. The initial ban was enacted under President Obama. President Trump directed its repeal through an executive order. That repeal was later overturned in court, reinstating the ban. The newly published 2024 rule formally reestablishes this prohibition on federal lands, which include national preserves in Alaska.

The rule specifically references Alaska state regulations that permit baiting. Those state rules allow the use of foods like bacon, doughnuts, meat waste, and other human food. Hunters typically use cheap food high in fat and sugar, placing it in steel barrels or garbage containers. They monitor the bait and set up a nearby shelter for close-range shooting.

Stakeholder Positions

Interior Secretary Doug Burgum stated the prior rule allowing baiting was prepared in response to demands from Alaska residents. He said it aimed to strengthen their voice in decisions concerning land, wildlife, and local traditions. Hunters and some Alaska residents have defended baiting as a state-managed tradition.

Environmental groups and animal welfare organizations strongly oppose the practice. They have condemned the previous allowance of baiting as indefensible and inexcusable. Opponents argue the practice conditions bears to associate humans with food, leading to increased aggression. Drew Robertson, a representative of Humane World for Animals, called the return of the practice cruel and dangerous for both wildlife and people.

Scientific and Ethical Concerns

Scientific evidence confirms that bear baiting alters bear behavior. It makes bears more aggressive and increases risks to park visitors. This feeding teaches bears to seek out human-provided food, creating potentially dangerous encounters.

The practice also raises broader ethical questions about sport hunting. Many hunters view baiting as contrary to the concept of fair chase. It eliminates the challenge of tracking and stalking game. The ethical debate extends to wildlife welfare, questioning the impact of conditioning wild animals to depend on artificial food sources.

This rule change occurred in a context of other controversial hunting practices being permitted in Alaska. These have included shooting bears from helicopters, shooting swimming caribou from motorboats, killing wolf pups in their dens, and using artificial lights to draw bears out of dens. While bear baiting is not highly unusual nationally-about a dozen states allow similar practices-more states do not permit it.

The Biden administration's 2024 reinstatement of the ban on federal lands is the definitive policy action. It closes the latest chapter in a regulatory debate focused on wildlife safety and the ethics of human intervention in wild spaces.

Related coverage

More from Centros y voluntariado